HRAI-GO: Human-centred Regulatory AI, Governance Observatory
HRAI-GO: Human-centred Regulatory AI, Governance Observatory — comparative module: base taxonomy and declared extensions
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo
Módulo comparativo do HRAI-GO (Human-centred Regulatory AI, Governance Observatory): as 12 categorias e os 25 critérios de Alanoca et al. (2025), com as definições originais, e as extensões declaradas E1 a E7 (ESP-ONT-02, RF-16). As escalas dos critérios (E4) aguardam aprovação humana.
Página gerada do grafo (scripts/ontologia/publicar_iris.py). Em amarelo, o que o raciocinador inferiu, com a regra. 214 termos e indivíduos.
AIActChapter
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#AIActChapter- tipo
- owl:Class
Chapter of Regulation (EU) 2024/1689 (AI Act).
Chapter I: General provisions (Art. 1-4, including AI literacy, Art. 4)
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#AIAct_ChapterI- tipo
- owl:NamedIndividual, comp:AIActChapter
Chapter II: Prohibited AI practices (Art. 5)
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#AIAct_ChapterII- tipo
- owl:NamedIndividual, comp:AIActChapter
Chapter III: High-risk AI systems (Art. 6-49)
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#AIAct_ChapterIII- tipo
- owl:NamedIndividual, comp:AIActChapter
Chapter IV: Transparency obligations for certain AI systems (Art. 50)
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#AIAct_ChapterIV- tipo
- owl:NamedIndividual, comp:AIActChapter
Chapter IX: Post-market monitoring, information sharing and market surveillance (Art. 72-94)
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#AIAct_ChapterIX- tipo
- owl:NamedIndividual, comp:AIActChapter
Chapter V: General-purpose AI models (Art. 51-56)
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#AIAct_ChapterV- tipo
- owl:NamedIndividual, comp:AIActChapter
Chapter VI: Measures in support of innovation (Art. 57-63)
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#AIAct_ChapterVI- tipo
- owl:NamedIndividual, comp:AIActChapter
Chapter VII: Governance (Art. 64-70)
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#AIAct_ChapterVII- tipo
- owl:NamedIndividual, comp:AIActChapter
Chapter VIII: EU database for high-risk AI systems (Art. 71)
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#AIAct_ChapterVIII- tipo
- owl:NamedIndividual, comp:AIActChapter
Chapter X: Codes of conduct and guidelines (Art. 95-96)
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#AIAct_ChapterX- tipo
- owl:NamedIndividual, comp:AIActChapter
Chapter XII: Penalties (Art. 99-101)
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#AIAct_ChapterXII- tipo
- owl:NamedIndividual, comp:AIActChapter
Crianças e vulneráveis
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Area_ChildrenVulnerable- tipo
- owl:NamedIndividual, skos:Concept, hrai:SubstantiveArea
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_03
- skos:editorialNote
- Mapeamentos para NIST, AI Act e critérios: revisados pelo autor (D-03, 17/11/2026).
- skos:inScheme
- comp:AreasSubstantivas
- skos:notation
- children-vulnerable
- skos:related
- comp:C07_Individuals
- comp:areaAIActChapter
- comp:AIAct_ChapterII
- comp:areaAIActChapter
- comp:AIAct_ChapterIII
- comp:areaNistFunction
- comp:NIST_Map
- hrai:displayKey
- topics:children-vulnerable
- hrai:displayOrder
- 24
Infraestrutura computacional
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Area_ComputeInfrastructure- tipo
- owl:NamedIndividual, skos:Concept, hrai:SubstantiveArea
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_03
- skos:editorialNote
- Mapeamentos para NIST, AI Act e critérios: revisados pelo autor (D-03, 17/11/2026).
- skos:inScheme
- comp:AreasSubstantivas
- skos:notation
- compute-infrastructure
- skos:related
- comp:E2_PrimaryObjective
- hrai:displayKey
- topics:compute-infrastructure
- hrai:displayOrder
- 9
Direitos autorais
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Area_CopyrightIp- tipo
- owl:NamedIndividual, skos:Concept, hrai:SubstantiveArea
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_03
- skos:editorialNote
- Mapeamentos para NIST, AI Act e critérios: revisados pelo autor (D-03, 17/11/2026).
- skos:inScheme
- comp:AreasSubstantivas
- skos:notation
- copyright-ip
- comp:areaAIActChapter
- comp:AIAct_ChapterV
- comp:areaNistFunction
- comp:NIST_Govern
- hrai:displayKey
- topics:copyright-ip
- hrai:displayOrder
- 23
Governança de dados
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Area_DataGovernance- tipo
- owl:NamedIndividual, skos:Concept, hrai:SubstantiveArea
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_03
- skos:editorialNote
- Mapeamentos para NIST, AI Act e critérios: revisados pelo autor (D-03, 17/11/2026).
- skos:inScheme
- comp:AreasSubstantivas
- skos:notation
- data-governance
- skos:related
- comp:C03_DigitalLegalMaturity
- comp:areaAIActChapter
- comp:AIAct_ChapterIII
- comp:areaNistFunction
- comp:NIST_Manage
- comp:areaNistFunction
- comp:NIST_Map
- hrai:displayKey
- topics:data-governance
- hrai:displayOrder
- 11
Soberania de dados
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Area_DataSovereignty- tipo
- owl:NamedIndividual, skos:Concept, hrai:SubstantiveArea
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_03
- skos:editorialNote
- Mapeamentos para NIST, AI Act e critérios: revisados pelo autor (D-03, 17/11/2026).
- skos:inScheme
- comp:AreasSubstantivas
- skos:notation
- data-sovereignty
- skos:related
- comp:E2_PrimaryObjective
- hrai:displayKey
- topics:data-sovereignty
- hrai:displayOrder
- 12
Energia e meio ambiente
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Area_EnergyEnvironment- tipo
- owl:NamedIndividual, skos:Concept, hrai:SubstantiveArea
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_03
- skos:editorialNote
- Mapeamentos para NIST, AI Act e critérios: revisados pelo autor (D-03, 17/11/2026).
- skos:inScheme
- comp:AreasSubstantivas
- skos:notation
- energy-environment
- comp:areaAIActChapter
- comp:AIAct_ChapterV
- comp:areaNistFunction
- comp:NIST_Map
- comp:areaNistFunction
- comp:NIST_Measure
- hrai:displayKey
- topics:energy-environment
- hrai:displayOrder
- 10
Capacidade de fiscalização
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Area_EnforcementCapacity- tipo
- owl:NamedIndividual, skos:Concept, hrai:SubstantiveArea
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_03
- skos:editorialNote
- Mapeamentos para NIST, AI Act e critérios: revisados pelo autor (D-03, 17/11/2026).
- skos:inScheme
- comp:AreasSubstantivas
- skos:notation
- enforcement-capacity
- skos:related
- comp:C10_ExistingOrNewAgency
- skos:related
- comp:E6_ImplementationCapacity
- comp:areaAIActChapter
- comp:AIAct_ChapterIX
- comp:areaAIActChapter
- comp:AIAct_ChapterXII
- comp:areaNistFunction
- comp:NIST_Govern
- hrai:displayKey
- topics:enforcement-capacity
- hrai:displayOrder
- 4
Financiamento e continuidade
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Area_FundingContinuity- tipo
- owl:NamedIndividual, skos:Concept, hrai:SubstantiveArea
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_03
- skos:editorialNote
- Mapeamentos para NIST, AI Act e critérios: revisados pelo autor (D-03, 17/11/2026).
- skos:inScheme
- comp:AreasSubstantivas
- skos:notation
- funding-continuity
- skos:related
- comp:E6_ImplementationCapacity
- comp:areaNistFunction
- comp:NIST_Govern
- hrai:displayKey
- topics:funding-continuity
- hrai:displayOrder
- 27
IA generativa e modelos de propósito geral
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Area_GenerativeGpai- tipo
- owl:NamedIndividual, skos:Concept, hrai:SubstantiveArea
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_03
- skos:editorialNote
- Mapeamentos para NIST, AI Act e critérios: revisados pelo autor (D-03, 17/11/2026).
- skos:inScheme
- comp:AreasSubstantivas
- skos:notation
- generative-gpai
- skos:related
- comp:C04_AppliesToGenerativeAI
- skos:related
- comp:C24_TechnologyFocused
- skos:scopeNote
- Área acrescentada pela extensão E3; ainda não aparece na cúpula da câmara.
- comp:areaAIActChapter
- comp:AIAct_ChapterV
- comp:areaNistFunction
- comp:NIST_Govern
- comp:areaNistFunction
- comp:NIST_Map
- hrai:displayOrder
- 29
Avaliação de impacto
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Area_ImpactAssessment- tipo
- owl:NamedIndividual, skos:Concept, hrai:SubstantiveArea
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_03
- skos:editorialNote
- Mapeamentos para NIST, AI Act e critérios: revisados pelo autor (D-03, 17/11/2026).
- skos:inScheme
- comp:AreasSubstantivas
- skos:notation
- impact-assessment
- skos:related
- comp:C09_ThirdPartyAudits
- skos:related
- comp:C17_Auditing
- comp:areaAIActChapter
- comp:AIAct_ChapterIII
- comp:areaNistFunction
- comp:NIST_Map
- comp:areaNistFunction
- comp:NIST_Measure
- hrai:displayKey
- topics:impact-assessment
- hrai:displayOrder
- 2
Integridade da informação
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Area_InfoIntegrity- tipo
- owl:NamedIndividual, skos:Concept, hrai:SubstantiveArea
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_03
- skos:editorialNote
- Mapeamentos para NIST, AI Act e critérios: revisados pelo autor (D-03, 17/11/2026).
- skos:inScheme
- comp:AreasSubstantivas
- skos:notation
- info-integrity
- skos:related
- comp:C04_AppliesToGenerativeAI
- comp:areaAIActChapter
- comp:AIAct_ChapterIV
- comp:areaNistFunction
- comp:NIST_Manage
- comp:areaNistFunction
- comp:NIST_Map
- hrai:displayKey
- topics:info-integrity
- hrai:displayOrder
- 22
Inovação e sandbox
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Area_InnovationSandbox- tipo
- owl:NamedIndividual, skos:Concept, hrai:SubstantiveArea
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_03
- skos:editorialNote
- Mapeamentos para NIST, AI Act e critérios: revisados pelo autor (D-03, 17/11/2026).
- skos:inScheme
- comp:AreasSubstantivas
- skos:notation
- innovation-sandbox
- skos:related
- comp:C12_RegulatorySandboxes
- comp:areaAIActChapter
- comp:AIAct_ChapterVI
- hrai:displayKey
- topics:innovation-sandbox
- hrai:displayOrder
- 16
Alinhamento internacional
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Area_InternationalAlignment- tipo
- owl:NamedIndividual, skos:Concept, hrai:SubstantiveArea
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_03
- skos:editorialNote
- Mapeamentos para NIST, AI Act e critérios: revisados pelo autor (D-03, 17/11/2026).
- skos:inScheme
- comp:AreasSubstantivas
- skos:notation
- international-alignment
- skos:related
- comp:C19_InternationalCooperation
- comp:areaNistFunction
- comp:NIST_Govern
- hrai:displayKey
- topics:international-alignment
- hrai:displayOrder
- 20
Trabalho
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Area_LaborRelations- tipo
- owl:NamedIndividual, skos:Concept, hrai:SubstantiveArea
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_03
- skos:editorialNote
- Mapeamentos para NIST, AI Act e critérios: revisados pelo autor (D-03, 17/11/2026).
- skos:inScheme
- comp:AreasSubstantivas
- skos:notation
- labor-relations
- skos:related
- comp:C05_Industry
- comp:areaAIActChapter
- comp:AIAct_ChapterIII
- comp:areaNistFunction
- comp:NIST_Map
- hrai:displayKey
- topics:labor-relations
- hrai:displayOrder
- 15
Língua e cultura
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Area_LanguageCulture- tipo
- owl:NamedIndividual, skos:Concept, hrai:SubstantiveArea
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_03
- skos:editorialNote
- Mapeamentos para NIST, AI Act e critérios: revisados pelo autor (D-03, 17/11/2026).
- skos:inScheme
- comp:AreasSubstantivas
- skos:notation
- language-culture
- skos:related
- comp:E2_PrimaryObjective
- comp:areaNistFunction
- comp:NIST_Map
- hrai:displayKey
- topics:language-culture
- hrai:displayOrder
- 13
Responsabilização
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Area_Liability- tipo
- owl:NamedIndividual, skos:Concept, hrai:SubstantiveArea
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_03
- skos:editorialNote
- Mapeamentos para NIST, AI Act e critérios: revisados pelo autor (D-03, 17/11/2026).
- skos:inScheme
- comp:AreasSubstantivas
- skos:notation
- liability
- skos:related
- comp:C11_Liability
- comp:areaNistFunction
- comp:NIST_Govern
- comp:areaNistFunction
- comp:NIST_Manage
- hrai:displayKey
- topics:liability
- hrai:displayOrder
- 6
Monitoramento e revisão
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Area_MonitoringLearning- tipo
- owl:NamedIndividual, skos:Concept, hrai:SubstantiveArea
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_03
- skos:editorialNote
- Mapeamentos para NIST, AI Act e critérios: revisados pelo autor (D-03, 17/11/2026).
- skos:inScheme
- comp:AreasSubstantivas
- skos:notation
- monitoring-learning
- skos:related
- comp:C08_ContinuedReporting
- comp:areaAIActChapter
- comp:AIAct_ChapterIX
- comp:areaNistFunction
- comp:NIST_Manage
- comp:areaNistFunction
- comp:NIST_Measure
- hrai:displayKey
- topics:monitoring-learning
- hrai:displayOrder
- 28
Ciência e modelos abertos
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Area_OpenSourceScience- tipo
- owl:NamedIndividual, skos:Concept, hrai:SubstantiveArea
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_03
- skos:editorialNote
- Mapeamentos para NIST, AI Act e critérios: revisados pelo autor (D-03, 17/11/2026).
- skos:inScheme
- comp:AreasSubstantivas
- skos:notation
- open-source-science
- skos:related
- comp:E2_PrimaryObjective
- comp:areaAIActChapter
- comp:AIAct_ChapterV
- hrai:displayKey
- topics:open-source-science
- hrai:displayOrder
- 18
Instituições de supervisão
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Area_OversightInstitutions- tipo
- owl:NamedIndividual, skos:Concept, hrai:SubstantiveArea
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_03
- skos:editorialNote
- Mapeamentos para NIST, AI Act e critérios: revisados pelo autor (D-03, 17/11/2026).
- skos:inScheme
- comp:AreasSubstantivas
- skos:notation
- oversight-institutions
- skos:related
- comp:C10_ExistingOrNewAgency
- skos:related
- comp:C18_TechnicalExpertise
- comp:areaAIActChapter
- comp:AIAct_ChapterVII
- comp:areaNistFunction
- comp:NIST_Govern
- hrai:displayKey
- topics:oversight-institutions
- hrai:displayOrder
- 3
Participação social
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Area_Participation- tipo
- owl:NamedIndividual, skos:Concept, hrai:SubstantiveArea
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_03
- skos:editorialNote
- Mapeamentos para NIST, AI Act e critérios: revisados pelo autor (D-03, 17/11/2026).
- skos:inScheme
- comp:AreasSubstantivas
- skos:notation
- participation
- skos:related
- comp:C20_CivilSocietyInclusion
- skos:related
- comp:C21_PrivateSectorInclusion
- skos:related
- comp:E7_ImplementationParticipation
- comp:areaAIActChapter
- comp:AIAct_ChapterX
- comp:areaNistFunction
- comp:NIST_Govern
- hrai:displayKey
- topics:participation
- hrai:displayOrder
- 26
IA no setor público
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Area_PublicSectorUse- tipo
- owl:NamedIndividual, skos:Concept, hrai:SubstantiveArea
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_03
- skos:editorialNote
- Mapeamentos para NIST, AI Act e critérios: revisados pelo autor (D-03, 17/11/2026).
- skos:inScheme
- comp:AreasSubstantivas
- skos:notation
- public-sector-use
- skos:related
- comp:C06_Government
- comp:areaAIActChapter
- comp:AIAct_ChapterIII
- comp:areaNistFunction
- comp:NIST_Govern
- hrai:displayKey
- topics:public-sector-use
- hrai:displayOrder
- 8
Desigualdade regional
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Area_RegionalInequality- tipo
- owl:NamedIndividual, skos:Concept, hrai:SubstantiveArea
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_03
- skos:editorialNote
- Mapeamentos para NIST, AI Act e critérios: revisados pelo autor (D-03, 17/11/2026).
- skos:inScheme
- comp:AreasSubstantivas
- skos:notation
- regional-inequality
- skos:related
- comp:E2_PrimaryObjective
- comp:areaNistFunction
- comp:NIST_Map
- hrai:displayKey
- topics:regional-inequality
- hrai:displayOrder
- 25
Direitos e contestação
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Area_RightsRedress- tipo
- owl:NamedIndividual, skos:Concept, hrai:SubstantiveArea
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_03
- skos:editorialNote
- Mapeamentos para NIST, AI Act e critérios: revisados pelo autor (D-03, 17/11/2026).
- skos:inScheme
- comp:AreasSubstantivas
- skos:notation
- rights-redress
- skos:related
- comp:C23_ExPost
- comp:areaAIActChapter
- comp:AIAct_ChapterIX
- comp:areaNistFunction
- comp:NIST_Manage
- hrai:displayKey
- topics:rights-redress
- hrai:displayOrder
- 5
Classificação de risco
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Area_RiskClassification- tipo
- owl:NamedIndividual, skos:Concept, hrai:SubstantiveArea
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_03
- skos:editorialNote
- Mapeamentos para NIST, AI Act e critérios: revisados pelo autor (D-03, 17/11/2026).
- skos:inScheme
- comp:AreasSubstantivas
- skos:notation
- risk-classification
- skos:related
- comp:C22_ExAnte
- skos:related
- comp:C25_ApplicationFocused
- comp:areaAIActChapter
- comp:AIAct_ChapterII
- comp:areaAIActChapter
- comp:AIAct_ChapterIII
- comp:areaNistFunction
- comp:NIST_Map
- hrai:displayKey
- topics:risk-classification
- hrai:displayOrder
- 1
Segurança e defesa
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Area_SecurityDefense- tipo
- owl:NamedIndividual, skos:Concept, hrai:SubstantiveArea
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_03
- skos:editorialNote
- Mapeamentos para NIST, AI Act e critérios: revisados pelo autor (D-03, 17/11/2026).
- skos:inScheme
- comp:AreasSubstantivas
- skos:notation
- security-defense
- skos:related
- comp:E2_PrimaryObjective
- comp:areaAIActChapter
- comp:AIAct_ChapterI
- comp:areaNistFunction
- comp:NIST_Manage
- comp:areaNistFunction
- comp:NIST_Map
- hrai:displayKey
- topics:security-defense
- hrai:displayOrder
- 21
Concorrência e pequenas empresas
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Area_SmeCompetition- tipo
- owl:NamedIndividual, skos:Concept, hrai:SubstantiveArea
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_03
- skos:editorialNote
- Mapeamentos para NIST, AI Act e critérios: revisados pelo autor (D-03, 17/11/2026).
- skos:inScheme
- comp:AreasSubstantivas
- skos:notation
- sme-competition
- skos:related
- comp:C05_Industry
- comp:areaAIActChapter
- comp:AIAct_ChapterVI
- hrai:displayKey
- topics:sme-competition
- hrai:displayOrder
- 17
Normas e certificação
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Area_StandardsCertification- tipo
- owl:NamedIndividual, skos:Concept, hrai:SubstantiveArea
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_03
- skos:editorialNote
- Mapeamentos para NIST, AI Act e critérios: revisados pelo autor (D-03, 17/11/2026).
- skos:inScheme
- comp:AreasSubstantivas
- skos:notation
- standards-certification
- skos:related
- comp:C16_StandardSetting
- comp:areaAIActChapter
- comp:AIAct_ChapterIII
- comp:areaNistFunction
- comp:NIST_Measure
- hrai:displayKey
- topics:standards-certification
- hrai:displayOrder
- 19
Transparência e registro
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Area_Transparency- tipo
- owl:NamedIndividual, skos:Concept, hrai:SubstantiveArea
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_03
- skos:editorialNote
- Mapeamentos para NIST, AI Act e critérios: revisados pelo autor (D-03, 17/11/2026).
- skos:inScheme
- comp:AreasSubstantivas
- skos:notation
- transparency
- skos:related
- comp:C08_ContinuedReporting
- comp:areaAIActChapter
- comp:AIAct_ChapterIV
- comp:areaAIActChapter
- comp:AIAct_ChapterVIII
- comp:areaNistFunction
- comp:NIST_Govern
- comp:areaNistFunction
- comp:NIST_Measure
- hrai:displayKey
- topics:transparency
- hrai:displayOrder
- 7
Formação e capacitação
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Area_WorkforceSkills- tipo
- owl:NamedIndividual, skos:Concept, hrai:SubstantiveArea
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_03
- skos:editorialNote
- Mapeamentos para NIST, AI Act e critérios: revisados pelo autor (D-03, 17/11/2026).
- skos:inScheme
- comp:AreasSubstantivas
- skos:notation
- workforce-skills
- skos:related
- comp:C18_TechnicalExpertise
- comp:areaAIActChapter
- comp:AIAct_ChapterI
- comp:areaNistFunction
- comp:NIST_Govern
- hrai:displayKey
- topics:workforce-skills
- hrai:displayOrder
- 14
Áreas substantivas do HRAI-GO (extensão E3)
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#AreasSubstantivas- tipo
- skos:ConceptScheme
- skos:scopeNote
- Áreas substantivas (extensão E3, RF-05): as 28 áreas da cúpula da câmara mais IA generativa/GPAI. Os mapeamentos para funções do NIST AI RMF 1.0, capítulos do AI Act (Regulamento (UE) 2024/1689) e critérios da taxonomia foram propostos pela sessão do loop e revisados pelo autor (decisão D-03, 17/11/2026).
Law adoption
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#C01_LawAdoption- tipo
- skos:Concept, hrai:RegulatoryDesignCriterion
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_02
- dcterms:source
- https://doi.org/10.1145/3715275.3732059
- skos:altLabel
- Adoção como lei
- skos:broader
- comp:Cat_Status
- skos:editorialNote
- Escala E4 aprovada pelo autor (D-02, 17/11/2026).
- skos:inScheme
- comp:TaxonomiaAlanoca2025
- skos:notation
- C01
Tracks whether AI legislation has been formally adopted as law yet.
Novelty of legal regime
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#C02_NoveltyOfLegalRegime- tipo
- skos:Concept, hrai:RegulatoryDesignCriterion
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_02
- dcterms:source
- https://doi.org/10.1145/3715275.3732059
- skos:altLabel
- Lei nova ou adaptada
- skos:broader
- comp:Cat_Novelty
- skos:editorialNote
- Escala E4 aprovada pelo autor (D-02, 17/11/2026).
- skos:inScheme
- comp:TaxonomiaAlanoca2025
- skos:notation
- C02
This metric assesses whether the legislation is specifically developed to govern AI (new legislation) or if it adapts existing legal frameworks to apply to AI systems. The goal is to distinguish between laws crafted with AI in mind and those repurposed to address AI-related concerns.
Maturity of AI-relevant regulatory landscape
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#C03_DigitalLegalMaturity- tipo
- skos:Concept, hrai:RegulatoryDesignCriterion
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_02
- dcterms:source
- https://doi.org/10.1145/3715275.3732059
- skos:altLabel
- Maturidade do ecossistema regulatório relevante para IA
- skos:broader
- comp:Cat_DigitalLegalMaturity
- skos:editorialNote
- Escala E4 aprovada pelo autor (D-02, 17/11/2026).
- skos:inScheme
- comp:TaxonomiaAlanoca2025
- skos:notation
- C03
Maturity assesses the overall advancement and robustness of a jurisdiction’s digital and AI governance framework. Jurisdictions with mature digital regulatory landscapes typically demonstrate comprehensive AI strategies and AI-adjacent regulations (e.g., data protection, platform content moderation).
Applies to Generative AI
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#C04_AppliesToGenerativeAI- tipo
- skos:Concept, hrai:RegulatoryDesignCriterion
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_02
- dcterms:source
- https://doi.org/10.1145/3715275.3732059
- skos:altLabel
- Aplica-se a IA generativa/GPAI
- skos:broader
- comp:Cat_Scope
- skos:editorialNote
- Escala E4 aprovada pelo autor (D-02, 17/11/2026).
- skos:editorialNote
- Tabelas 1 a 10 (critério sem definição em prosa na seção 5.1)
- skos:inScheme
- comp:TaxonomiaAlanoca2025
- skos:notation
- C04
Applies to Generative AI
Industry
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#C05_Industry- tipo
- skos:Concept, hrai:RegulatoryDesignCriterion
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_02
- dcterms:source
- https://doi.org/10.1145/3715275.3732059
- skos:altLabel
- Indústria
- skos:broader
- comp:Cat_Reach
- skos:editorialNote
- Escala E4 aprovada pelo autor (D-02, 17/11/2026).
- skos:inScheme
- comp:TaxonomiaAlanoca2025
- skos:notation
- C05
Regulations targeting private sector companies and their AI applications.
Government/Federal Agencies
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#C06_Government- tipo
- skos:Concept, hrai:RegulatoryDesignCriterion
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_02
- dcterms:source
- https://doi.org/10.1145/3715275.3732059
- skos:altLabel
- Governo
- skos:broader
- comp:Cat_Reach
- skos:editorialNote
- Escala E4 aprovada pelo autor (D-02, 17/11/2026).
- skos:inScheme
- comp:TaxonomiaAlanoca2025
- skos:notation
- C06
Regulations guiding AI use within public sector entities.
Individuals/Citizens
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#C07_Individuals- tipo
- skos:Concept, hrai:RegulatoryDesignCriterion
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_02
- dcterms:source
- https://doi.org/10.1145/3715275.3732059
- skos:altLabel
- Indivíduos
- skos:broader
- comp:Cat_Reach
- skos:editorialNote
- Escala E4 aprovada pelo autor (D-02, 17/11/2026).
- skos:inScheme
- comp:TaxonomiaAlanoca2025
- skos:notation
- C07
Regulations addressing the use of AI systems by individuals.
Continued Reporting
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#C08_ContinuedReporting- tipo
- skos:Concept, hrai:RegulatoryDesignCriterion
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_02
- dcterms:source
- https://doi.org/10.1145/3715275.3732059
- skos:altLabel
- Relatórios contínuos
- skos:broader
- comp:Cat_Enforcement
- skos:editorialNote
- Escala E4 aprovada pelo autor (D-02, 17/11/2026).
- skos:inScheme
- comp:TaxonomiaAlanoca2025
- skos:notation
- C08
Mandates periodic updates or assessments to monitor compliance over time.
Third-Party Audits
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#C09_ThirdPartyAudits- tipo
- skos:Concept, hrai:RegulatoryDesignCriterion
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_02
- dcterms:source
- https://doi.org/10.1145/3715275.3732059
- skos:altLabel
- Auditoria de terceiros
- skos:broader
- comp:Cat_Enforcement
- skos:editorialNote
- Escala E4 aprovada pelo autor (D-02, 17/11/2026).
- skos:inScheme
- comp:TaxonomiaAlanoca2025
- skos:notation
- C09
Independent assessments conducted by external organizations to evaluate and verify compliance with certain standards.
Existing Agency or New Agency
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#C10_ExistingOrNewAgency- tipo
- skos:Concept, hrai:RegulatoryDesignCriterion
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_02
- dcterms:source
- https://doi.org/10.1145/3715275.3732059
- skos:altLabel
- Agência existente ou nova
- skos:broader
- comp:Cat_Enforcement
- skos:editorialNote
- Escala E4 aprovada pelo autor (D-02, 17/11/2026).
- skos:inScheme
- comp:TaxonomiaAlanoca2025
- skos:notation
- C10
Reflects whether enforcement is handled by existing regulatory bodies or if new agencies are established specifically for AI oversight.
Liability
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#C11_Liability- tipo
- skos:Concept, hrai:RegulatoryDesignCriterion
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_02
- dcterms:source
- https://doi.org/10.1145/3715275.3732059
- skos:altLabel
- Responsabilização
- skos:broader
- comp:Cat_Enforcement
- skos:editorialNote
- Escala E4 aprovada pelo autor (D-02, 17/11/2026).
- skos:inScheme
- comp:TaxonomiaAlanoca2025
- skos:notation
- C11
This metric examines whether actors bear legal responsibility when AI systems cause harm or fail to comply with regulations.
Regulatory Sandboxes
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#C12_RegulatorySandboxes- tipo
- skos:Concept, hrai:RegulatoryDesignCriterion
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_02
- dcterms:source
- https://doi.org/10.1145/3715275.3732059
- skos:altLabel
- Sandbox regulatório
- skos:broader
- comp:Cat_Enforcement
- skos:editorialNote
- Escala E4 aprovada pelo autor (D-02, 17/11/2026).
- skos:inScheme
- comp:TaxonomiaAlanoca2025
- skos:notation
- C12
Controlled environments allowing companies to test AI systems under regulatory supervision.
Criminal Charges
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#C13_CriminalCharges- tipo
- skos:Concept, hrai:RegulatoryDesignCriterion
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_02
- dcterms:source
- https://doi.org/10.1145/3715275.3732059
- skos:altLabel
- Sanções penais
- skos:broader
- comp:Cat_Sanctions
- skos:editorialNote
- Escala E4 aprovada pelo autor (D-02, 17/11/2026).
- skos:inScheme
- comp:TaxonomiaAlanoca2025
- skos:notation
- C13
Frameworks that enable the prosecution of individuals, organizations, or entities for unlawful actions, negligence, or harm caused by AI systems.
Fines
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#C14_Fines- tipo
- skos:Concept, hrai:RegulatoryDesignCriterion
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_02
- dcterms:source
- https://doi.org/10.1145/3715275.3732059
- skos:altLabel
- Multas
- skos:broader
- comp:Cat_Sanctions
- skos:editorialNote
- Escala E4 aprovada pelo autor (D-02, 17/11/2026).
- skos:inScheme
- comp:TaxonomiaAlanoca2025
- skos:notation
- C14
Financial penalties imposed on non-compliant actors for violating AI regulations.
Temporary Injunctions
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#C15_TemporaryInjunctions- tipo
- skos:Concept, hrai:RegulatoryDesignCriterion
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_02
- dcterms:source
- https://doi.org/10.1145/3715275.3732059
- skos:altLabel
- Injunções temporárias
- skos:broader
- comp:Cat_Sanctions
- skos:editorialNote
- Escala E4 aprovada pelo autor (D-02, 17/11/2026).
- skos:inScheme
- comp:TaxonomiaAlanoca2025
- skos:notation
- C15
Legal orders that temporarily halt the development, deployment, or continued operation of AI systems suspected of posing significant risks or violating regulations.
Standard Setting
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#C16_StandardSetting- tipo
- skos:Concept, hrai:RegulatoryDesignCriterion
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_02
- dcterms:source
- https://doi.org/10.1145/3715275.3732059
- skos:altLabel
- Definição de padrões
- skos:broader
- comp:Cat_Operationalization
- skos:editorialNote
- Escala E4 aprovada pelo autor (D-02, 17/11/2026).
- skos:inScheme
- comp:TaxonomiaAlanoca2025
- skos:notation
- C16
Establishes technical and procedural benchmarks for AI development and deployment.
Auditing
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#C17_Auditing- tipo
- skos:Concept, hrai:RegulatoryDesignCriterion
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_02
- dcterms:source
- https://doi.org/10.1145/3715275.3732059
- skos:altLabel
- Auditoria
- skos:broader
- comp:Cat_Operationalization
- skos:editorialNote
- Escala E4 aprovada pelo autor (D-02, 17/11/2026).
- skos:inScheme
- comp:TaxonomiaAlanoca2025
- skos:notation
- C17
Internal or external audits evaluate AI system performance and adherence to standards.
Technical Expertise
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#C18_TechnicalExpertise- tipo
- skos:Concept, hrai:RegulatoryDesignCriterion
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_02
- dcterms:source
- https://doi.org/10.1145/3715275.3732059
- skos:altLabel
- Expertise técnica
- skos:broader
- comp:Cat_Operationalization
- skos:editorialNote
- Escala E4 aprovada pelo autor (D-02, 17/11/2026).
- skos:inScheme
- comp:TaxonomiaAlanoca2025
- skos:notation
- C18
Highlights whether frameworks mandate and have the means to include technical expertise within regulatory bodies, ensuring informed oversight.
International Cooperation
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#C19_InternationalCooperation- tipo
- skos:Concept, hrai:RegulatoryDesignCriterion
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_02
- dcterms:source
- https://doi.org/10.1145/3715275.3732059
- skos:altLabel
- Alinhamento a marcos globais
- skos:broader
- comp:Cat_InternationalCooperation
- skos:editorialNote
- Escala E4 aprovada pelo autor (D-02, 17/11/2026).
- skos:inScheme
- comp:TaxonomiaAlanoca2025
- skos:notation
- C19
This metric evaluates alignment with global frameworks (e.g., OECD AI principles), which reflects efforts and the willingness of jurisdictions to contribute to international AI governance norms.
Civil Society Inclusion
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#C20_CivilSocietyInclusion- tipo
- skos:Concept, hrai:RegulatoryDesignCriterion
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_02
- dcterms:source
- https://doi.org/10.1145/3715275.3732059
- skos:altLabel
- Inclusão da sociedade civil
- skos:broader
- comp:Cat_StakeholderConsultation
- skos:editorialNote
- Escala E4 aprovada pelo autor (D-02, 17/11/2026).
- skos:inScheme
- comp:TaxonomiaAlanoca2025
- skos:notation
- C20
Reflects engagement with nongovernmental organizations, ensuring public interest is represented.
Private Sector Inclusion
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#C21_PrivateSectorInclusion- tipo
- skos:Concept, hrai:RegulatoryDesignCriterion
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_02
- dcterms:source
- https://doi.org/10.1145/3715275.3732059
- skos:altLabel
- Inclusão do setor privado
- skos:broader
- comp:Cat_StakeholderConsultation
- skos:editorialNote
- Escala E4 aprovada pelo autor (D-02, 17/11/2026).
- skos:inScheme
- comp:TaxonomiaAlanoca2025
- skos:notation
- C21
Captures whether industry stakeholders contribute to the legislative process.
Ex Ante
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#C22_ExAnte- tipo
- skos:Concept, hrai:RegulatoryDesignCriterion
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_02
- dcterms:source
- https://doi.org/10.1145/3715275.3732059
- skos:altLabel
- Ex ante
- skos:broader
- comp:Cat_RegulatoryApproach
- skos:editorialNote
- Escala E4 aprovada pelo autor (D-02, 17/11/2026).
- skos:inScheme
- comp:TaxonomiaAlanoca2025
- skos:notation
- C22
A preventive approach that addresses risks before they arise, emphasizing measures like pre-market approval to ensure AI systems meet safety and compliance standards in advance.
Ex Post
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#C23_ExPost- tipo
- skos:Concept, hrai:RegulatoryDesignCriterion
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_02
- dcterms:source
- https://doi.org/10.1145/3715275.3732059
- skos:altLabel
- Ex post
- skos:broader
- comp:Cat_RegulatoryApproach
- skos:editorialNote
- Escala E4 aprovada pelo autor (D-02, 17/11/2026).
- skos:inScheme
- comp:TaxonomiaAlanoca2025
- skos:notation
- C23
A reactive approach that evaluates AI systems after deployment, focusing on retrospective assessments and legal remedies. It allows individuals affected by AI to pursue recourse, including the right to file lawsuits.
Technology-Focused
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#C24_TechnologyFocused- tipo
- skos:Concept, hrai:RegulatoryDesignCriterion
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_02
- dcterms:source
- https://doi.org/10.1145/3715275.3732059
- skos:altLabel
- Tecnologia
- skos:broader
- comp:Cat_RegulationLayer
- skos:editorialNote
- Escala E4 aprovada pelo autor (D-02, 17/11/2026).
- skos:inScheme
- comp:TaxonomiaAlanoca2025
- skos:notation
- C24
Regulations target AI infrastructure (e.g., dual-use foundation models).
Application-Focused
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#C25_ApplicationFocused- tipo
- skos:Concept, hrai:RegulatoryDesignCriterion
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_02
- dcterms:source
- https://doi.org/10.1145/3715275.3732059
- skos:altLabel
- Aplicação
- skos:broader
- comp:Cat_RegulationLayer
- skos:editorialNote
- Escala E4 aprovada pelo autor (D-02, 17/11/2026).
- skos:inScheme
- comp:TaxonomiaAlanoca2025
- skos:notation
- C25
Legislative focus on specific AI use cases (e.g., social scoring). This provides tailored oversight for distinct risk categories and applications.
Maturity of the Digital Legal Landscape
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Cat_DigitalLegalMaturity- tipo
- skos:Concept
- dcterms:source
- https://doi.org/10.1145/3715275.3732059
- skos:altLabel
- Maturidade do ecossistema legal digital
- skos:inScheme
- comp:TaxonomiaAlanoca2025
- skos:topConceptOf
- comp:TaxonomiaAlanoca2025
Maturity assesses the overall advancement and robustness of a jurisdiction’s digital and AI governance framework. Jurisdictions with mature digital regulatory landscapes typically demonstrate comprehensive AI strategies and AI-adjacent regulations (e.g., data protection, platform content moderation).
Enforcement
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Cat_Enforcement- tipo
- skos:Concept
- dcterms:source
- https://doi.org/10.1145/3715275.3732059
- skos:altLabel
- Fiscalização
- skos:inScheme
- comp:TaxonomiaAlanoca2025
- skos:topConceptOf
- comp:TaxonomiaAlanoca2025
This metric focuses on the mechanisms and processes used to monitor, verify, and enforce compliance with AI regulations.
International Cooperation
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Cat_InternationalCooperation- tipo
- skos:Concept
- dcterms:source
- https://doi.org/10.1145/3715275.3732059
- skos:altLabel
- Cooperação internacional
- skos:inScheme
- comp:TaxonomiaAlanoca2025
- skos:topConceptOf
- comp:TaxonomiaAlanoca2025
This metric evaluates alignment with global frameworks (e.g., OECD AI principles), which reflects efforts and the willingness of jurisdictions to contribute to international AI governance norms.
Novelty
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Cat_Novelty- tipo
- skos:Concept
- dcterms:source
- https://doi.org/10.1145/3715275.3732059
- skos:altLabel
- Novidade
- skos:inScheme
- comp:TaxonomiaAlanoca2025
- skos:topConceptOf
- comp:TaxonomiaAlanoca2025
This metric assesses whether the legislation is specifically developed to govern AI (new legislation) or if it adapts existing legal frameworks to apply to AI systems. The goal is to distinguish between laws crafted with AI in mind and those repurposed to address AI-related concerns.
Operationalization
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Cat_Operationalization- tipo
- skos:Concept
- dcterms:source
- https://doi.org/10.1145/3715275.3732059
- skos:altLabel
- Operacionalização
- skos:inScheme
- comp:TaxonomiaAlanoca2025
- skos:topConceptOf
- comp:TaxonomiaAlanoca2025
Reach
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Cat_Reach- tipo
- skos:Concept
- dcterms:source
- https://doi.org/10.1145/3715275.3732059
- skos:altLabel
- Alcance
- skos:inScheme
- comp:TaxonomiaAlanoca2025
- skos:topConceptOf
- comp:TaxonomiaAlanoca2025
Identifies sectors subject to AI regulations:
Regulation Layer
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Cat_RegulationLayer- tipo
- skos:Concept
- dcterms:source
- https://doi.org/10.1145/3715275.3732059
- skos:altLabel
- Camada regulada
- skos:inScheme
- comp:TaxonomiaAlanoca2025
- skos:topConceptOf
- comp:TaxonomiaAlanoca2025
Regulatory Approach
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Cat_RegulatoryApproach- tipo
- skos:Concept
- dcterms:source
- https://doi.org/10.1145/3715275.3732059
- skos:altLabel
- Abordagem regulatória
- skos:inScheme
- comp:TaxonomiaAlanoca2025
- skos:topConceptOf
- comp:TaxonomiaAlanoca2025
Sanctions
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Cat_Sanctions- tipo
- skos:Concept
- dcterms:source
- https://doi.org/10.1145/3715275.3732059
- skos:altLabel
- Sanções
- skos:inScheme
- comp:TaxonomiaAlanoca2025
- skos:topConceptOf
- comp:TaxonomiaAlanoca2025
This category outlines the legal powers granted to enforcement bodies to ensure compliance with AI regulations and impose penalties on violators.
Scope
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Cat_Scope- tipo
- skos:Concept
- dcterms:source
- https://doi.org/10.1145/3715275.3732059
- skos:altLabel
- Escopo
- skos:inScheme
- comp:TaxonomiaAlanoca2025
- skos:topConceptOf
- comp:TaxonomiaAlanoca2025
Applies to Generative AI
Stakeholder Consultation
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Cat_StakeholderConsultation- tipo
- skos:Concept
- dcterms:source
- https://doi.org/10.1145/3715275.3732059
- skos:altLabel
- Consulta a partes interessadas
- skos:inScheme
- comp:TaxonomiaAlanoca2025
- skos:topConceptOf
- comp:TaxonomiaAlanoca2025
Status
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Cat_Status- tipo
- skos:Concept
- dcterms:source
- https://doi.org/10.1145/3715275.3732059
- skos:altLabel
- Status
- skos:inScheme
- comp:TaxonomiaAlanoca2025
- skos:topConceptOf
- comp:TaxonomiaAlanoca2025
Tracks whether AI legislation has been formally adopted as law yet.
DesignProfile
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#DesignProfile- tipo
- owl:Class
Reading label derived from a combination of coded criteria (R28); the criteria stay visible.
Forma jurídica
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#E1_LegalForm- tipo
- skos:Concept, hrai:RegulatoryDesignCriterion
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_02
- rdfs:seeAlso
- https://doi.org/10.1145/3715275.3732059
- skos:altLabel
- Legal form
- skos:editorialNote
- Escala E4 aprovada pelo autor (D-02, 17/11/2026).
- skos:example
- PBIA (plano), Reino Unido (princípios não estatutários), NIST AI RMF (guia voluntário).
- skos:inScheme
- comp:ExtensoesHRAIGO
- skos:notation
- E1
- skos:scopeNote
- Extensão declarada da taxonomia de Alanoca, Gur-Arieh, Zick e Klyman (2025), Comparing Apples to Oranges, FAccT '25, doi:10.1145/3715275.3732059. Não altera as definições originais.
- skos:topConceptOf
- comp:ExtensoesHRAIGO
Amplia o critério Status para instrumentos não vinculantes: lei, projeto de lei, plano, princípios não estatutários e guia voluntário.
Objetivo primário
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#E2_PrimaryObjective- tipo
- skos:Concept, hrai:RegulatoryDesignCriterion
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_02
- rdfs:seeAlso
- https://doi.org/10.1145/3715275.3732059
- skos:altLabel
- Primary objective
- skos:example
- O caráter desenvolvimentista e de soberania do modelo brasileiro (PBIA).
- skos:inScheme
- comp:ExtensoesHRAIGO
- skos:notation
- E2
- skos:scopeNote
- Extensão declarada da taxonomia de Alanoca, Gur-Arieh, Zick e Klyman (2025), Comparing Apples to Oranges, FAccT '25, doi:10.1145/3715275.3732059. Não altera as definições originais.
- skos:topConceptOf
- comp:ExtensoesHRAIGO
Objetivo que o instrumento declara como principal: direitos, inovação, desenvolvimento e soberania, ou segurança.
Cobertura substantiva
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#E3_SubstantiveCoverage- tipo
- skos:Concept, hrai:RegulatoryDesignCriterion
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_02
- rdfs:seeAlso
- https://doi.org/10.1145/3715275.3732059
- skos:altLabel
- Substantive coverage
- skos:editorialNote
- Escala E4 aprovada pelo autor (D-02, 17/11/2026).
- skos:example
- Lacunas de conteúdo: energia, crianças, desigualdade regional, participação.
- skos:inScheme
- comp:ExtensoesHRAIGO
- skos:notation
- E3
- skos:scopeNote
- Extensão declarada da taxonomia de Alanoca, Gur-Arieh, Zick e Klyman (2025), Comparing Apples to Oranges, FAccT '25, doi:10.1145/3715275.3732059. Não altera as definições originais.
- skos:topConceptOf
- comp:ExtensoesHRAIGO
Áreas substantivas cobertas (as 28 áreas da câmara mais IA generativa e modelos de propósito geral), ligadas aos critérios quando houver relação.
Codificação em escala, com evidência por valor
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#E4_ScaledCoding- tipo
- skos:Concept, hrai:RegulatoryDesignCriterion
- rdfs:seeAlso
- https://doi.org/10.1145/3715275.3732059
- skos:altLabel
- Scaled coding with evidence per value
- skos:example
- Valores comparáveis e rastreáveis, em vez de descrições.
- skos:inScheme
- comp:ExtensoesHRAIGO
- skos:notation
- E4
- skos:scopeNote
- Extensão declarada da taxonomia de Alanoca, Gur-Arieh, Zick e Klyman (2025), Comparing Apples to Oranges, FAccT '25, doi:10.1145/3715275.3732059. Não altera as definições originais.
- skos:topConceptOf
- comp:ExtensoesHRAIGO
Cada valor é registrado numa escala aprovada e ligado ao dispositivo que o justifica.
Codificação por versão do instrumento
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#E5_VersionedCoding- tipo
- skos:Concept, hrai:RegulatoryDesignCriterion
- rdfs:seeAlso
- https://doi.org/10.1145/3715275.3732059
- skos:altLabel
- Coding per instrument version
- skos:example
- PL 2338 de 2023 e de 2024; instrumentos revogados (EO 14110).
- skos:inScheme
- comp:ExtensoesHRAIGO
- skos:notation
- E5
- skos:scopeNote
- Extensão declarada da taxonomia de Alanoca, Gur-Arieh, Zick e Klyman (2025), Comparing Apples to Oranges, FAccT '25, doi:10.1145/3715275.3732059. Não altera as definições originais.
- skos:topConceptOf
- comp:ExtensoesHRAIGO
A codificação pertence a uma versão do instrumento; mudou o texto, a codificação é refeita.
Capacidade de implementação
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#E6_ImplementationCapacity- tipo
- skos:Concept, hrai:RegulatoryDesignCriterion
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_02
- rdfs:seeAlso
- https://doi.org/10.1145/3715275.3732059
- skos:altLabel
- Implementation capacity
- skos:editorialNote
- Escala E4 aprovada pelo autor (D-02, 17/11/2026).
- skos:example
- Orçamento e pessoal de supervisão (Eixo 5 do PBIA).
- skos:inScheme
- comp:ExtensoesHRAIGO
- skos:notation
- E6
- skos:scopeNote
- Extensão declarada da taxonomia de Alanoca, Gur-Arieh, Zick e Klyman (2025), Comparing Apples to Oranges, FAccT '25, doi:10.1145/3715275.3732059. Não altera as definições originais.
- skos:topConceptOf
- comp:ExtensoesHRAIGO
Orçamento e pessoal disponíveis para supervisionar e implementar o instrumento.
Participação na implementação
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#E7_ImplementationParticipation- tipo
- skos:Concept, hrai:RegulatoryDesignCriterion
- dcterms:isReferencedBy
- https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/data/regulatory/decisoes#D_02
- rdfs:seeAlso
- https://doi.org/10.1145/3715275.3732059
- skos:altLabel
- Participation in implementation
- skos:editorialNote
- Escala E4 aprovada pelo autor (D-02, 17/11/2026).
- skos:example
- Deliberação pública ao vivo e Shadow Council.
- skos:inScheme
- comp:ExtensoesHRAIGO
- skos:notation
- E7
- skos:scopeNote
- Extensão declarada da taxonomia de Alanoca, Gur-Arieh, Zick e Klyman (2025), Comparing Apples to Oranges, FAccT '25, doi:10.1145/3715275.3732059. Não altera as definições originais.
- skos:topConceptOf
- comp:ExtensoesHRAIGO
Participação de pessoas e grupos na implementação e na padronização, além da consulta no processo legislativo.
Extensões declaradas E1 a E7 do HRAI-GO
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#ExtensoesHRAIGO- tipo
- skos:ConceptScheme
- rdfs:seeAlso
- https://doi.org/10.1145/3715275.3732059
- skos:scopeNote
- Extensão declarada da taxonomia de Alanoca, Gur-Arieh, Zick e Klyman (2025), Comparing Apples to Oranges, FAccT '25, doi:10.1145/3715275.3732059. Não altera as definições originais.
Regulação horizontal por risco
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#HorizontalRiskBasedRegulation- tipo
- owl:NamedIndividual, comp:DesignProfile
Lei ou projeto de lei (E1), com requisitos ex ante altos (C22) e foco em aplicações (C25).
GOVERN
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#NIST_Govern- tipo
- owl:NamedIndividual, comp:NistFunction
MANAGE
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#NIST_Manage- tipo
- owl:NamedIndividual, comp:NistFunction
MAP
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#NIST_Map- tipo
- owl:NamedIndividual, comp:NistFunction
MEASURE
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#NIST_Measure- tipo
- owl:NamedIndividual, comp:NistFunction
NistFunction
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#NistFunction- tipo
- owl:Class
Function of the NIST AI Risk Management Framework 1.0 (govern, map, measure, manage).
sem texto formal
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C01_0- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 0
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C01_LawAdoption
proposta em tramitação
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C01_1- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 1
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C01_LawAdoption
aprovada em uma casa
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C01_2- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 2
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C01_LawAdoption
adotada
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C01_3- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 3
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C01_LawAdoption
adapta marco existente
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C02_0- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 0
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C02_NoveltyOfLegalRegime
misto
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C02_1- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 1
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C02_NoveltyOfLegalRegime
lei nova específica para IA
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C02_2- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 2
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C02_NoveltyOfLegalRegime
incipiente
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C03_0- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 0
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C03_DigitalLegalMaturity
emergente
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C03_1- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 1
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C03_DigitalLegalMaturity
intermediário
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C03_2- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 2
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C03_DigitalLegalMaturity
maduro
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C03_3- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 3
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C03_DigitalLegalMaturity
não se aplica
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C04_0- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 0
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C04_AppliesToGenerativeAI
menção secundária
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C04_1- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 1
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C04_AppliesToGenerativeAI
regras específicas
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C04_2- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 2
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C04_AppliesToGenerativeAI
não visa
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C05_0- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 0
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C05_Industry
visa de forma secundária
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C05_1- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 1
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C05_Industry
alvo principal
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C05_2- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 2
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C05_Industry
não visa
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C06_0- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 0
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C06_Government
visa de forma secundária
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C06_1- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 1
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C06_Government
alvo principal
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C06_2- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 2
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C06_Government
não visa
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C07_0- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 0
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C07_Individuals
visa de forma secundária
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C07_1- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 1
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C07_Individuals
alvo principal
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C07_2- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 2
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C07_Individuals
ausente
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C08_0- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 0
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C08_ContinuedReporting
previsto de forma genérica
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C08_1- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 1
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C08_ContinuedReporting
previsto com regra operacional
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C08_2- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 2
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C08_ContinuedReporting
ausente
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C09_0- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 0
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C09_ThirdPartyAudits
previsto de forma genérica
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C09_1- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 1
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C09_ThirdPartyAudits
previsto com regra operacional
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C09_2- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 2
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C09_ThirdPartyAudits
só agências existentes
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C10_0- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 0
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C10_ExistingOrNewAgency
sistema que coordena as existentes
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C10_1- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 1
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C10_ExistingOrNewAgency
agência nova
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C10_2- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 2
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C10_ExistingOrNewAgency
ausente
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C11_0- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 0
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C11_Liability
previsto de forma genérica
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C11_1- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 1
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C11_Liability
previsto com regra operacional
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C11_2- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 2
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C11_Liability
ausente
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C12_0- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 0
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C12_RegulatorySandboxes
previsto de forma genérica
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C12_1- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 1
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C12_RegulatorySandboxes
previsto com regra operacional
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C12_2- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 2
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C12_RegulatorySandboxes
ausente
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C13_0- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 0
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C13_CriminalCharges
previsto de forma genérica
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C13_1- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 1
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C13_CriminalCharges
previsto com regra operacional
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C13_2- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 2
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C13_CriminalCharges
ausente
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C14_0- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 0
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C14_Fines
previstas sem teto
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C14_1- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 1
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C14_Fines
previstas com teto definido
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C14_2- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 2
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C14_Fines
ausente
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C15_0- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 0
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C15_TemporaryInjunctions
previsto de forma genérica
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C15_1- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 1
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C15_TemporaryInjunctions
previsto com regra operacional
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C15_2- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 2
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C15_TemporaryInjunctions
ausente
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C16_0- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 0
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C16_StandardSetting
previsto de forma genérica
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C16_1- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 1
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C16_StandardSetting
previsto com regra operacional
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C16_2- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 2
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C16_StandardSetting
ausente
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C17_0- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 0
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C17_Auditing
previsto de forma genérica
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C17_1- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 1
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C17_Auditing
previsto com regra operacional
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C17_2- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 2
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C17_Auditing
ausente
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C18_0- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 0
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C18_TechnicalExpertise
previsto de forma genérica
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C18_1- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 1
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C18_TechnicalExpertise
previsto com regra operacional
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C18_2- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 2
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C18_TechnicalExpertise
sem alinhamento
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C19_0- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 0
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C19_InternationalCooperation
alinha definições
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C19_1- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 1
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C19_InternationalCooperation
alinhamento explícito a marcos globais
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C19_2- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 2
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C19_InternationalCooperation
ausente
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C20_0- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 0
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C20_CivilSocietyInclusion
baixa
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C20_1- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 1
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C20_CivilSocietyInclusion
média
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C20_2- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 2
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C20_CivilSocietyInclusion
alta
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C20_3- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 3
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C20_CivilSocietyInclusion
ausente
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C21_0- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 0
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C21_PrivateSectorInclusion
baixa
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C21_1- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 1
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C21_PrivateSectorInclusion
média
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C21_2- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 2
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C21_PrivateSectorInclusion
alta
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C21_3- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 3
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C21_PrivateSectorInclusion
nenhum
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C22_0- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 0
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C22_ExAnte
baixo
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C22_1- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 1
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C22_ExAnte
médio
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C22_2- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 2
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C22_ExAnte
alto
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C22_3- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 3
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C22_ExAnte
nenhum
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C23_0- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 0
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C23_ExPost
baixo
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C23_1- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 1
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C23_ExPost
médio
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C23_2- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 2
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C23_ExPost
alto
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C23_3- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 3
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C23_ExPost
não
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C24_0- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 0
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C24_TechnologyFocused
camada secundária
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C24_1- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 1
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C24_TechnologyFocused
camada principal
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C24_2- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 2
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C24_TechnologyFocused
não
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C25_0- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 0
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C25_ApplicationFocused
camada secundária
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C25_1- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 1
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C25_ApplicationFocused
camada principal
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_C25_2- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 2
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:C25_ApplicationFocused
guia voluntário
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_E1_0- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 0
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:E1_LegalForm
princípios não estatutários
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_E1_1- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 1
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:E1_LegalForm
plano ou estratégia
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_E1_2- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 2
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:E1_LegalForm
lei ou projeto de lei
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_E1_3- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 3
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:E1_LegalForm
sem cobertura
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_E3_0- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 0
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:E3_SubstantiveCoverage
só em proposta ou plano
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_E3_1- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 1
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:E3_SubstantiveCoverage
em instrumento vigente
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_E3_2- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 2
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:E3_SubstantiveCoverage
sem indicador
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_E6_0- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 0
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:E6_ImplementationCapacity
indicador abaixo do limiar
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_E6_1- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 1
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:E6_ImplementationCapacity
indicador no limiar ou acima
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_E6_2- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 2
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:E6_ImplementationCapacity
ausente
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_E7_0- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 0
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:E7_ImplementationParticipation
baixa
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_E7_1- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 1
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:E7_ImplementationParticipation
média
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_E7_2- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 2
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:E7_ImplementationParticipation
alta
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Nivel_E7_3- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- skos:notation
- 3
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:E7_ImplementationParticipation
R28_HorizontalRiskBasedProfile
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#R28_HorizontalRiskBasedProfile- tipo
- swrl:Imp
Reading label derived from coded values; the criteria stay visible. Depends on approved E4 scales and reviewed codings.
ScaleLevel
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#ScaleLevel- tipo
- owl:Class
Level of an approved E4 scale: numeric value (skos:notation) and label. Approved by the author (D-02).
Taxonomy of AI regulation (Alanoca et al., 2025)
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#TaxonomiaAlanoca2025- tipo
- skos:ConceptScheme
- dcterms:bibliographicCitation
- Alanoca, S.; Gur-Arieh, S.; Zick, T.; Klyman, K. Comparing Apples to Oranges: A Taxonomy for Navigating the Global Landscape of AI Regulation. FAccT '25. doi:10.1145/3715275.3732059. Seção 5.1 (Selected Metrics); critério Scope a partir das Tabelas 1 a 10.
- dcterms:source
- https://doi.org/10.1145/3715275.3732059
desenvolvimento e soberania
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Valor_E2_DesenvolvimentoESoberania- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:E2_PrimaryObjective
direitos
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Valor_E2_Direitos- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:E2_PrimaryObjective
inovação
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Valor_E2_Inovação- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:E2_PrimaryObjective
segurança
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#Valor_E2_Segurança- tipo
- skos:Concept, comp:ScaleLevel
- comp:scaleLevelOf
- comp:E2_PrimaryObjective
areaAIActChapter
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#areaAIActChapter- tipo
- owl:ObjectProperty
- rdfs:domain
- hrai:SubstantiveArea
- rdfs:range
- comp:AIActChapter
AI Act chapter that addresses the area (proposed mapping, pending review).
areaNistFunction
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#areaNistFunction- tipo
- owl:ObjectProperty
- rdfs:domain
- hrai:SubstantiveArea
- rdfs:range
- comp:NistFunction
NIST AI RMF 1.0 function related to the area (proposed mapping, pending review).
hasDesignProfile
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#hasDesignProfile- tipo
- owl:ObjectProperty
- rdfs:range
- comp:DesignProfile
Inferred (R28): the coded instrument version reads as this design profile.
scaleLevelOf
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#scaleLevelOf- tipo
- owl:ObjectProperty
- rdfs:range
- hrai:RegulatoryDesignCriterion
Criterion whose approved E4 scale this level belongs to.
var_R28_HorizontalRiskBasedProfile_c1
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#var_R28_HorizontalRiskBasedProfile_c1- tipo
- swrl:Variable
var_R28_HorizontalRiskBasedProfile_c2
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#var_R28_HorizontalRiskBasedProfile_c2- tipo
- swrl:Variable
var_R28_HorizontalRiskBasedProfile_c3
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#var_R28_HorizontalRiskBasedProfile_c3- tipo
- swrl:Variable
var_R28_HorizontalRiskBasedProfile_d1
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#var_R28_HorizontalRiskBasedProfile_d1- tipo
- swrl:Variable
var_R28_HorizontalRiskBasedProfile_d2
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#var_R28_HorizontalRiskBasedProfile_d2- tipo
- swrl:Variable
var_R28_HorizontalRiskBasedProfile_d3
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#var_R28_HorizontalRiskBasedProfile_d3- tipo
- swrl:Variable
var_R28_HorizontalRiskBasedProfile_p1
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#var_R28_HorizontalRiskBasedProfile_p1- tipo
- swrl:Variable
var_R28_HorizontalRiskBasedProfile_p2
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#var_R28_HorizontalRiskBasedProfile_p2- tipo
- swrl:Variable
var_R28_HorizontalRiskBasedProfile_p3
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#var_R28_HorizontalRiskBasedProfile_p3- tipo
- swrl:Variable
var_R28_HorizontalRiskBasedProfile_v
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#var_R28_HorizontalRiskBasedProfile_v- tipo
- swrl:Variable
var_R28_HorizontalRiskBasedProfile_x1
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#var_R28_HorizontalRiskBasedProfile_x1- tipo
- swrl:Variable
var_R28_HorizontalRiskBasedProfile_x2
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#var_R28_HorizontalRiskBasedProfile_x2- tipo
- swrl:Variable
var_R28_HorizontalRiskBasedProfile_x3
https://hrai-go.aeonbridge.io/ontology/comparativo#var_R28_HorizontalRiskBasedProfile_x3- tipo
- swrl:Variable